Cookie Control

This site uses cookies to store information on your computer.
I am happy to proceed
Image

MUSSORGSKY: Boris Godunov (Andrzej Bielecki/ Boris Christoff/ Eugenia Zareska/ French National Radio Orchestra/ Issay Dobrowen/ Kim Borg/ Mark Obert-Thorn/ Nicolai Gedda/ Russian Chorus of Paris) (Naxos Historical: 8.110242-44)



Shipping time: In stock | Expected delivery 1-2 days | Free UK Delivery
Modest MUSSORGSKY (1839-1881)

Boris Godunov


The masters of Russian opera owed much to Italian models.Glinka, father of the genre, spent valuable time in Italy; Tchaikovsky loved toholiday there, soaking up the ambience; and even that rough diamond Mussorgskytook inspiration from an Italian - in his case, Verdi. In 1862 La forza deldestino was given its premi?â?¿re in St Petersburg: it was an episodic 'revenger'stragedy' in which the action was played out against a background of tavern,church and war, with the chorus usually representing the common people. It evenfeatured a comic monk. La forza del destino cast a long shadow on Mussorgsky'smasterpieces Boris Godunov and Khovanshchina - and in view of the reputation itgained for bringing bad luck, perhaps it put the evil eye on Boris. Certainly thismagnificent opera, which seems to enshrine the very essence of the Russiansoul, has had a tortuous route to establishing itself in the repertoire.


Mussorgsky wrote his first version of Boris Godunov in1868-69 at the prompting of the historian Vladimir Nikolsky, basing it on thedrama by Pushkin and the history of Russia by Karamzin - Nikolsky and VladimirStasov assisted with the libretto. This seven-scene version immediately raninto trouble, paralleling what would happen to Janacˇek a generation later.It had virtually no female interest and the music seemed barbaric to therefined tastes of the day. Mussorgsky's particular genius was akin to theaspect he presented in the famous portrait by Repin, rather rough and unkempt,but what he heard in his mind's ear was truer to nature and the spirit ofMother Russia than the music being produced by his friends among the 'MightyHandful' (Balakirev, Rimsky-Korsakov, Cui and Borodin). Rebuffed by thecommittee of the Imperial Theatres, he produced a second version, cutting thescene which took place outside St Basil's Cathedral, inserting a new act (someof which, already written, had been left out of his first version) andcomposing a new ending set in the Kromy Forest. Boris's monologue became morelike an aria and his Clock Scene made its appearance. That unforgettablecharacter of the Simpleton was transferred from the St Basil's scene to theKromy Forest and the opera now ended with his lament. Other changes increasedthe female involvement but the main gain on this front was the advent ofMarina. This second version of Boris was influenced not just by Dargomyzhskybut by Rimsky-Korsakov, with whom Mussorgsky stayed during its composition(Rimsky-Korsakov was working on The Maid of Pskov).


The Coronation Scene was performed in concert in 1872 andthe Polish Act and the Inn Scene were done at the Mariinsky in 1873; but theopera as a whole was not heard until 1874, and even then cuts were made by theconductor Napravnik. Yet the work had a considerable success. Boris wasconsidered interesting even by its detractors but by the time Mussorgsky died,aged just 42, in 1881 it had fallen into disuse. His friend Rimsky-Korsakovstarted tinkering with it in 1888 and by 1896 had produced a new version,rescored, changed in many details and with the order of the final two scenesreversed so that the opera ended with Boris's death. Two years later FyodorChaliapin took the title r?â??le for the first time and it was he who made thework famous. In the 1920s Mussorgsky's original score was published, but itmade little headway - more notice was taken of Ippolitov-Ivanov's rescoring ofthe St Basil's scene, which was sometimes added to the rest (with theduplicated section of the Simpleton's part excised). A 1928 Leningradproduction of the Mussorgsky version was badly presented and failed, despitehaving Mark Reizen as Boris.


The Rimsky-Korsakov's version revised in 1906-08, with cutsrestored, did better, conquering all the major operatic centres throughChaliapin (other noted exponents of Boris were Adam Didur, Robert Radford,Carlo Galeffi, Vanni-Marcoux, Andre Pernet, Alexander Kipnis and Ezio Pinza).In Russia the Rimsky version also ruled, although at the Bolshoy the St Basil'sscene was restored and the Kromy Forest scene was placed in its rightfulposition at the end. This version was recorded in the late 1940s - Russianrecord buyers could choose between Reizen and Alexander Pirogov as Boris.Meanwhile in 1940 Shostakovich made his own orchestration, which sought tomediate between the ideals of Mussorgsky and Rimsky-Korsakov. To be fair toRimsky-Korsakov, he wrote of his effort: 'Mussorgsky's violent admirers frowneda bit, regretting something... But having arranged the new revision of BorisGodunov, I had not destroyed its original form, had not painted out the oldfrescoes for ever. If ever the conclusion is arrived at that the original isbetter, worthier than my revision, mine will be discarded, and Boris Godunovwill be performed according to the original score'. In the past few decadesthat point has been reached: Mussorgsky's original has taken over and now it isRimsky-Korsakov's score which is endangered.


Whichever version you espouse, Mussorgsky's opera is amasterwork full of magnificent music and pungent characterisation. Folk-songinspires many of its pages - a notable example is the great chorus in thePrologue, based on a tune Beethoven had already used on a smaller scale in hisSecond Razumovsky Quartet. Even more than most Russian music of the nineteenthcentury, Boris Godunov is also redolent of liturgical chant at almost everyturn. Larger-than-life characters such as Varlaam, Missail, the Hostess and theSimpleton provide diversions from the tortured character of Boris himself whois on stage for a relatively short time and always the chorus is there,representing the timeless stoicism of the Russian people.


Boris Christoff, Chaliapin's successor in the West, wassinging music from the opera in public as early as 1944 and soon beganprogramming Mussorgsky's songs, but he did not engage with the composer onstage until February 1947, when he sang Pimen in Rome to the Boris of TancrediPasero. That September they repeated their r?â??les at La Scala, with NicolaRossi-Lemeni as Varlaam; in February 1948 Christoff essayed the r?â??le of Dosifeiin Khovanshchina at Trieste, with Rossi-Lemeni as Khovansky, and the followingmonth Christoff replaced the scheduled Pasero as Boris at Cagliari, with TullioSerafin conducting. Christoff and Rossi-Lemeni became a double-act inKhovanshchina, finally in February 1949 reaching La Scala, where theirconductor was Issay Dobrowen. Meanwhile Christoff had sung in Mussorgsky'sSorochintsy Fair for Italian Radio (and he would soon do it on stage). InNovember 1949 he sang Boris in London (doing the Rimsky version in Russianwhile everyone else did the Mussorgsky version in English) and across New Year1950 he gave four performances at La Scala under Dobrowen. By the time thisrecording was made in 1952, he was steeped in Mussorgsky's music and, likeChaliapin before him, knew every note of the Rimsky-Korsakov Boris. It nowseems strange that he should have commandeered all three main bass r?â??les: aBoris with, say, Raphael Ari?â?½ as Pimen and Rossi-Lemeni as Varlaam would havebeen a great draw, but the new tape process made it possible - Christoff-Borisand Christoff-Pimen had to confront each other in Act IV - and Dobrowen and EMIwent along with the idea (which Christoff would repeat for stereo, thoughwithout Dobrowen). Whatever one thinks of the preponderance of Christoff'stones in the finished set, he sings well enough. To have the young Gedda as theFalse Dmitry, Eugenia Zareska as Marina and Kim Borg as the wily Jesuit Rangoniis also marvellous, but it is for Christoff and the conducting of Dobrowen thatthis set - the first to be available worldwide is treasured by opera buffs.


Facts
Item number 8110242-44
Barcode 636943124222
Release date 21/05/2004
Category Opera / Operetta | Classical Music
Label Naxos Records | Naxos Historical
Media type CD
Number of units 3
Performers
Artists Nicolai Gedda
Eugenia Zareska
Andrzej Bielecki
Boris Christoff
Kim Borg
Composers Modest Petrovich Mussorgsky
Conductors Issay Dobrowen
Orchestras French National Radio Orchestra
Russian Chorus of Paris
Producers Mark Obert-Thorn
Disc: 1
Boris Godunov
1 Prologue Scene 1: Introduction
2 Prologue Scene 1: People's Chorus - Nu, shtozh vy?
3 Prologue Scene 1: Shchelkalov's Address - Pravosla
4 Prologue Scene 1: Pilgrim's Chorus - Slava tebye
5 Prologue Scene 2: Introduction
6 Prologue Scene 2: People's Chorus - Da zdrastvuet
7 Prologue Scene 2: Entry of Boris - Skorbit dusha!
8 Prologue Scene 2: People's Chorus - Slava! Slava!
9 Act 1 Scene 1: Pimen's Mologue - Yeshcho odno posl
10 Act 1 Scene 1: Grigory's Dream - Bozhe krepki, pra
11 Act 1 Scene 1: Grigory's Dream - Ti vsyo pisal, i
12 Act 1 Scene 1: Boris's Crime - Davno, chestnoy oty
13 Act 1 Scene 1: Boris's Crime - Zvonyat k zautrenye
14 Act 1 Scene 2: Introduction
15 Act 1 Scene 2: Song of the Hostess - Poymala ya si
16 Act 1 Scene 2: Arrival of Varlaam and Missail - Zh
17 Act 1 Scene 2: Varlaam's Drinking Song - Kak vo go
18 Act 1 Scene 2: Grigory Questions the Hostess - Kak
19 Act 1 Scene 2: The Guard's Interrogation - Vy shto
20 Act 1 Scene 2: Grigory's Flight - Ya gramotny
Disc: 2
Boris Godunov
1 Act 2: Xenia's Lament - Gdye ty, zhenikh moy
2 Act 2: Song of the Flez - Kak komar drova rubil
3 Act 2: Clapping Game - Ekh, mama mamushka, vot tak
4 Act 2: Boris Consoles Xenia - Chevo?
5 Act 2: Map Scene - A ty, moy syn, chem zanyat?
6 Act 2: Boris's Monologue - Dostig ya vishey vlasti
7 Act 2: Shuysky's Treachery - Shto takoe?
8 Act 2: Tale of the Parakeet - Popinka nash sidyel
9 Act 2: Shuysky's Information - Veliky gosudar', ch
10 Act 2: Boris's Fears - Slikhal li ty, kogda-nibud
11 Act 2: Shuysky's Narration - V Ugliche, v soborye
12 Act 2: Clock Scene - Uf, tyazhelo!
13 Act 3 Scene 1: Chorus of Girls - Na Vislye lazurno
14 Act 3 Scene 1: Marina's Aira - Krasotka panna blag
15 Act 3 Scene 1: Marina's Aria - Skuchno Marinye
16 Act 3 Scene 1: Duet - Akh, eto ty, moy otyets!
17 Act 3 Scene 1: Duet - Krasoyu svoyeyu pleni samozv
18 Act 3 Scene 2: Dmitryi's Aria - V polnoch', v sadu
19 Act 3 Scene 2: Polonaise - Vashey strasti ya nye v
20 Act 3 Scene 2: Dimitri! Tsaryevich! Dimitri!
21 Act 3 Scene 2: Duet - Tebya, tebya, odnu, Marina
22 Act 3 Scene 2: Duet - O, tsaryevich, umolyayu
Disc: 3
Boris Godunov
1 Act 4 Scene 1: The Capture of Krushchyov - Vali sy
2 Act 4 Scene 1: The Mocking of Krushchyov - Nye sok
3 Act 4 Scene 1: The Taunting of the Simpleton - Trr
4 Act 4 Scene 1: Entrance of Varlaam and Missail - S
5 Act 4 Scene 1: Entrance of Dmitri - Slava, tebye,
6 Act 4 Scene 1: The Simpleton's Lament - Lyeytyes',
7 Act 4 Scene 2: The Duma of the Boyars - Shtozh, po
8 Act 4 Scene 2: Shuysky's Evidence and Boris's Deni
9 Act 4 Scene 2: Shuysky's Evidence and Boris's Deni
10 Act 4 Scene 2: Pimen's Narration - Smirenny inok
11 Act 4 Scene 2: Boris's Farewell and Prayer - Prosh
12 Act 4 Scene 2: Funeral Bell and Death of Boris - Z
13 Appendix: Prologue Scene 2: People's Chorus - Da z
14 Appendix: Prologue Scene 2: Entry of Boris - Skorb
15 Appendix: Act 2: Boris's Monologue - Dostig ya vis
16 Appendix: Act 2: Clock Scene - Uf, tyazhelo!
17 Appendix: Act 4 Scene 2: Boris's Farewell and Pray
18 Appendix: Act 4 Scene 2: Funeral Bell and Death of
Write your own review
You must log in to be able to write a review
If you like MUSSORGSKY: Boris Godunov (Andrzej Bielecki/ Boris Christoff/ Eugenia Zareska/ French National Radio Orchestra/ Issay Dobrowen/ Kim Borg/ Mark Obert-Thorn/ Nicolai Gedda/ Russian Chorus of Paris) (Naxos Historical: 8.110242-44), please tell your friends! You can easily share this page directly on Facebook, Twitter and via e-mail below.

You may also like.....

Image
£6.99
STRAUSS II, J.: Wiener Blut (Schwarzkopf, Gedda, Ackermann) (1954) (Alois Pernerstorfer/ Elisabeth Schwarzkopf/ Emmy Loose/ Erich Kunz/ Erika Koth/ Hanna Norbert/ Karel Stepanek/ Karl Donch/ Mark Obert-Thorn/ Nicolai Gedda/ Otto Ackermann/ Philharmonia Ch
Image
£6.99
STRAUSS: Eine Nacht in Venedig (Anton Diffring/ Elisabeth Schwarzkopf/ Emmy Loose/ Erich Kunz/ Hanna Ludwig/ Hanna Norbert/ Karel Stepanek/ Karl Donch/ Lea Seidl/ Mark Obert-Thorn/ Nicolai Gedda/ Otto Ackermann/ Peter Klein/ Philharmonia Chorus/ Philharmo
Image
£14.99
Verdi: Aida (Milanov, Bjorling, Perlea) (1955) (Naxos Historical: 8.111042-44)
Image
£12.99
STRAUSS II, J.: Die Fledermaus (The Bat) (Schwarzkopf, Gedda, Karajan) (1955) (Naxos Historical: 8.111036-37)
STRAUSS, R.: Four Last Songs / Arabella (highlights) (Schwarzkopf, Ackermann, Matacic) (1953, 1954) (Anny Felbermayer/ Elisabeth Schwarzkopf/ Harald Proglhof/ Josef Metternich/ Lovro von Matacic/ Mark Obert-Thorn/ Murray Dickie/ Nicolai Gedda/ Otto Ackerm 8111145 03/04/2006 £6.99
Puccini: Madama Butterfly (Callas) (Enrico Campi/ Herbert von Karajan/ Lucia Danieli/ Luisa Villa/ Maria Callas/ Mario Borriello/ Mario Carlin/ Mark Obert-Thorn/ Milan La Scala Chorus/ Milan La Scala Orchestra/ Nicolai Gedda/ Norberto Mola/ Plinio Clabass 8111026-27 03/01/2006 £12.99
ROSSINI: Il Turco in Italia (Callas, Rossi-Lemeni, Gavazzeni) (1954) (Franco Calabrese/ Giandrea Gavazzeni/ Jolanda Gardino/ Maria Callas/ Mariano Stabile/ Mark Obert-Thorn/ Milan La Scala Chorus/ Milan La Scala Orchestra/ Nicola Rossi-Lemeni/ Nicolai Ged 8111028-29 03/01/2006 £12.99
LEHAR: Das Land des Lachelns (Ackermann, Schwarzkopf) (1953) and excerpts from Lehar Operettas (Naxos Historical: 8.111016-17) 8111016-17 01/08/2005 £12.99
BORODIN: Prince Igor (Ivanov, Smolenskaya, Melik-Pashayev) (1951) (Naxos Historical: 8.111071-73) 8111071-73 02/05/2005 £14.99
Few in stock Buy +
LEHAR: The Merry Widow (Schwartzkopf, Kunz, Gedda) (1953) (Anton Niessner/ Elisabeth Schwarzkopf/ Emmy Loose/ Erich Kunz/ Joseph Schmidinger/ Mark Obert-Thorn/ Nicolai Gedda/ Otakar Kraus/ Otto Ackermann/ Philharmonia Chorus/ Philharmonia Orchestra) (Naxo 8111007 18/02/2005 £6.99
My account
My cart: 0 items